American restaurants

Mary Lou’s

3.1 21 reviews 04:00 PM - 02:00 AM 474 W Lake Dr, Montauk, NY 11954, United States

Discover this place

Mary Lou’s has quickly emerged as a premier dining destination in the heart of Montauk, and it’s easy to see why. With its upscale American cuisine and vibrant nightlife, the restaurant combines a classy bar lounge atmosphere with a lively energy that captivates patrons. Ely Cabrera's enthusiasm for the fried chicken croquettes and unforgettable oyster mushrooms paints a picture of the tantalizing offerings. The standout lobster pasta and succulent miso white fish further elevate the dining experience, showcasing the chef's artistry.

Customer reviews reveal more than just great food; they highlight the electric ambiance that leaves a lasting impression. Derrick Kurzrok applauds the meticulous attention to detail, the phenomenal service from staff like Yogi and Cormac, and the engaging live music that invites guests to unwind and be themselves. Danielle Moore echoes this sentiment, describing the atmosphere as unmatched and emphasizing the delightful seasonal shaved salad and perfectly mixed drinks.

As a food reviewer from Goto Where, I wholeheartedly recommend visiting Mary Lou’s. Whether you're after a delectable dinner or a vibrant night out, this establishment promises an unforgettable experience. Don’t miss out on adding this culinary gem to your Montauk itinerary!

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Outdoor seating
Dine-in
Delivery

Highlights

Great cocktails
Great wine list

Popular for

Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Dinner
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities

Bar onsite
Restroom

Atmosphere

Cozy
Trendy

Crowd

Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Mary Lou’s before visiting.

Reviews for Mary Lou’s

3.1

21 reviews

58%

100%

Review highlights

Based on 21 reviews

Mary Lou’s in Montauk is widely praised for its vibrant atmosphere that seamlessly blends a high-end dining experience with a lively nightlife vibe. Guests frequently highlight the restaurant’s diverse and innovative American menu, noting standout dishes like seafood and seasonal salads. The attention to detail extends beyond the food, with many appreciating the stylish ambiance, live music, and well-crafted cocktails. Service is often commended, reflecting a welcoming and attentive team. Overall, Mary Lou’s is recognized as a trendy hotspot that offers both exceptional cuisine and an engaging social scene, making it a favored destination for both dinner and late-night festivities.

Ely Cabrera

Aug 22, 2025

This is a new must try hot spot in Montauk. We started with the fried chicken croquettes and the oyster mushrooms. The mushrooms are a MUST. They were so fire. Then We ordered the lobster pasta that was absolutely fantastic and the miso white fish that was so delicious. The restaurant itself has a very sexy vibe. It also turns into a night club late in the evening. I recommend doing a late dinner there and then dance the night away. I 10/10 recommend adding this to your itinerary if you are taking a trip out there

Derrick Kurzrok

Aug 13, 2025

A new addition to Montauk, this high-end classy bar & lounge elevates the bar, literally. Live music and the freedom to be yourself sets the vibe here with live music, acoustic sets, and more late night. Not a single detail was left out in this trendy outpost of a West Palm Beach staple. Yogi & Cormac at the bar were outstanding! Crystal was a phenomenal server and the Executive Chef Nelly visited us also!

Danielle Moore

Aug 03, 2025

Made it into Mary Lou's MTK last night and it was truly a dream. I saw so many pictures online but they truly don't do it justice. The atmosphere is electric and the ambiance is unmatched. The seasonal shaved salad was so delicious and the drinks at the bar were made just right. I highly recommend making your way out if you can, it will be an amazing time!